Home of the The Hall of Ma'at on the Internet
Home
Discussion Forums
Papers
Authors

July 4, 2020, 3:31 pm UTC    
Bob
December 05, 2006 11:24PM
Katherine Reece Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Of course it's not .... but I assure you your idea
> as it stands now will never be accepted because
> you are ignoring something vital ... the ancient
> Egyptians themselves and what they believed.
>

With due respect.., I don't think anyone of our time can accurately presume to know what the ancient egyptians believed. We can presume to know with some accuracy what the ancient greeks believed- and certainly the romans. But the AE's remain largely inexplicable.., it is precisely this quality that draws so many of our time- including your commendable website- to the study of them.

They did inexplicable things:
the Giza plateau is seemingly an act of insanity..; whether a whole generation spent their entire lives building an edifice to house the remains of a trio of meglomaniacs.., or whether they envisioned them as some form of communication with one or another distant star system...,is equally implausible. As is the pharoanic predilection for preserving their corpses- sans brain and vital organs- for an afterlife they anticipated in some higher stellar kingdom[ did they not forsee some communication problems in fronting up to the annual astral fancy-dress ball minus a complete set of cerebral faculties ]?

There have been many attempts by diverse intuitions to divine the minds of those inscrutable AE's- some scholarly based on texts,picto-grams etc- but all those reliant upon the exactness of Champollion's translations; Some more imaginative such as Norman Mailer's "Ancient Evenings"- a commendable effort. But nothing that any among us can- without a pinch of salt- accept as a factual reality.

It is reminiscent of a more recent fable. Scott Fitzgerald once said to Ernest Hemingway:
"Ernest..,the VERY rich are different to you and I"[ Ernest's pragmatic response was - "yes.., they've got more money' ]

The AE"s are a little like the 'very rich'., they were different to you and I.


with respect.

Subject Author Posted

Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

creigs1707 December 01, 2006 07:22AM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Dave L December 01, 2006 07:32AM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

creigs1707 December 01, 2006 07:39AM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

creigs1707 December 01, 2006 07:42AM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Dave L December 01, 2006 07:59AM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

creigs1707 December 01, 2006 07:44AM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Don Barone December 01, 2006 09:04AM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Warwick L Nixon December 01, 2006 10:38AM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Ronald December 01, 2006 12:43PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Warwick L Nixon December 01, 2006 01:01PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Ronald December 01, 2006 05:57PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Warwick L Nixon December 02, 2006 10:15AM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Ronald December 03, 2006 04:45AM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Anthony December 03, 2006 12:29PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Katherine Reece December 03, 2006 12:33PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

creigs1707 December 03, 2006 01:30PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Anthony December 03, 2006 04:47PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Don Barone December 03, 2006 05:09PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Anthony December 03, 2006 06:27PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Don Barone December 03, 2006 06:34PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Anthony December 03, 2006 06:42PM

PS

Anthony December 03, 2006 06:43PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Warwick L Nixon December 04, 2006 11:16AM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Ronald December 03, 2006 05:32PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Anthony December 01, 2006 12:54PM

WOW !!!!!!!!

Don Barone December 01, 2006 04:08PM

re Eureka

Warwick L Nixon December 02, 2006 10:56AM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Jammer December 01, 2006 04:22PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Don Barone December 01, 2006 04:36PM

A Question to Creigs

Don Barone December 01, 2006 05:20PM

I do...

Anthony December 01, 2006 06:49PM

Re: I do...

Don Barone December 01, 2006 09:55PM

Re: I do...

Anthony December 02, 2006 06:15AM

Re: I do...

Don Barone December 02, 2006 08:11AM

Re: I do...

Anthony December 02, 2006 05:02PM

Re: I do...

Tommi Huhtamaki December 02, 2006 05:24PM

Re: I do...

Anthony December 02, 2006 06:15PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Jammer December 02, 2006 01:04PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

creigs1707 December 02, 2006 02:09PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Jammer December 04, 2006 12:59PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Warwick L Nixon December 04, 2006 01:05PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Anthony December 04, 2006 01:07PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Jammer December 04, 2006 01:14PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

creigs1707 December 03, 2006 04:52PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Don Barone December 03, 2006 04:57PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Anthony December 03, 2006 06:46PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

creigs1707 December 03, 2006 07:45PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Anthony December 03, 2006 08:05PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

creigs1707 December 03, 2006 08:26PM

ROFLMAO

Anthony December 03, 2006 08:49PM

Re: ROFLMAO

Don Barone December 03, 2006 09:16PM

Re: ROFLMAO

creigs1707 December 03, 2006 09:23PM

If I may say....

Katherine Reece December 03, 2006 09:48PM

Re: If I may say....

Greg Reeder December 04, 2006 12:19AM

Re: If I may say....

Katherine Reece December 04, 2006 12:45AM

Re: If I may say....

Rebby December 04, 2006 01:33AM

Re: If I may say....

creigs1707 December 04, 2006 05:28AM

Re: If I may say....

Don Barone December 04, 2006 06:52AM

Re: If I may say....

creigs1707 December 04, 2006 07:39AM

Re: If I may say....

C Wayne Taylor December 04, 2006 07:43AM

Re: If I may say....

Gerd VDC December 04, 2006 06:58AM

Re: If I may say....

lobo-hotei December 04, 2006 05:25PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

C Wayne Taylor December 04, 2006 07:34AM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

creigs1707 December 04, 2006 01:31PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

C Wayne Taylor December 04, 2006 03:49PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

creigs1707 December 04, 2006 06:28PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

C Wayne Taylor December 04, 2006 08:27PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

creigs1707 December 04, 2006 08:57PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

C Wayne Taylor December 05, 2006 07:13AM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Don Barone December 05, 2006 08:08AM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

C Wayne Taylor December 05, 2006 10:24AM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Jammer December 05, 2006 01:52PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

Ronald December 05, 2006 06:15PM

Methodological flaw - CAT related

Anthony December 07, 2006 01:21PM

Re: Giza Plateau - A New Interpretation that Incorporates Orthodox Theories

creigs1707 December 06, 2006 07:45AM

Some thoughts

Gerd VDC December 04, 2006 08:29AM

Re: Some thoughts

Hermione December 04, 2006 08:41AM

Re: Some thoughts

Gerd VDC December 04, 2006 09:09AM

Re: Some thoughts

creigs1707 December 04, 2006 12:15PM

Re: Some thoughts

Warwick L Nixon December 04, 2006 12:28PM

Re: Some thoughts

creigs1707 December 04, 2006 01:02PM

Re: Some thoughts

Warwick L Nixon December 04, 2006 01:09PM

Re: Some thoughts

Anthony December 04, 2006 01:30PM

Bingo!

Anthony December 04, 2006 12:55PM

Re: Bingo!

creigs1707 December 04, 2006 01:10PM

Re: Bingo!

Warwick L Nixon December 04, 2006 01:17PM

Re: Bingo!

Anthony December 04, 2006 01:17PM

Re: Bingo!

creigs1707 December 04, 2006 02:37PM

Re: Bingo!

Anthony December 04, 2006 03:42PM

Re: Bingo!

creigs1707 December 04, 2006 06:49PM

Re: Bingo!

Katherine Reece December 04, 2006 07:15PM

Re: Bingo!

Anthony December 04, 2006 08:02PM

Re: Bingo!

creigs1707 December 04, 2006 08:45PM

Re: Bingo!

Bob December 04, 2006 10:13PM

Re: Bingo!

creigs1707 December 05, 2006 08:46AM

Re: Bingo!

Anthony December 06, 2006 11:17AM

Re: Bingo!

creigs1707 December 06, 2006 04:46PM

Re: Bingo!

Katherine Reece December 04, 2006 11:08PM

Re: Some thoughts

Hermione December 04, 2006 01:22PM

Giza wheel continued...

Gerd VDC December 05, 2006 03:18AM

Re: Some thoughts

Don Barone December 04, 2006 01:09PM

Re: Some thoughts

Warwick L Nixon December 04, 2006 01:15PM

My question...

Morph December 04, 2006 11:06AM

Re: My question...

Don Barone December 04, 2006 01:24PM

Re: My question...

Morph December 04, 2006 01:44PM

Re: My question...

creigs1707 December 04, 2006 02:21PM

Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

creigs1707 December 05, 2006 08:45AM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Hermione December 05, 2006 09:18AM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Gerd VDC December 05, 2006 10:05AM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

creigs1707 December 05, 2006 11:00AM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Gerd VDC December 05, 2006 11:06AM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

creigs1707 December 05, 2006 11:59AM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Hermione December 05, 2006 12:03PM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Katherine Reece December 05, 2006 11:21AM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

C Wayne Taylor December 05, 2006 10:45AM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Gerd VDC December 05, 2006 11:08AM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Katherine Reece December 05, 2006 10:53AM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Rebby December 05, 2006 05:51PM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Katherine Reece December 05, 2006 06:19PM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Morph December 05, 2006 07:12PM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

creigs1707 December 05, 2006 07:22PM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Don Barone December 05, 2006 07:32PM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

creigs1707 December 06, 2006 07:53AM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Katherine Reece December 05, 2006 07:54PM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Bob December 05, 2006 11:24PM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Morph December 06, 2006 05:11AM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

creigs1707 December 06, 2006 07:51AM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Gerd VDC December 06, 2006 08:16AM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

creigs1707 December 06, 2006 08:40AM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Gerd VDC December 06, 2006 08:59AM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

creigs1707 December 06, 2006 09:56AM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Katherine Reece December 06, 2006 10:29AM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Morph December 06, 2006 12:24PM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

creigs1707 December 06, 2006 02:03PM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

C Wayne Taylor December 06, 2006 02:04PM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

creigs1707 December 06, 2006 02:23PM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

C Wayne Taylor December 06, 2006 04:38PM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

creigs1707 December 06, 2006 04:52PM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

C Wayne Taylor December 07, 2006 04:50AM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

creigs1707 December 07, 2006 05:30AM

Final word

Gerd VDC December 07, 2006 06:34AM

Re: Final word

creigs1707 December 07, 2006 07:38AM

Centroids, Ruffled Feathers, and the Pacific Northwest Tree Octopus

Anthony December 06, 2006 04:45PM

Re: Centroids, Ruffled Feathers, and the Pacific Northwest Tree Octopus

creigs1707 December 06, 2006 05:16PM

Moderation Note

Katherine Reece December 06, 2006 05:21PM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Katherine Reece December 06, 2006 10:31AM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Don Barone December 06, 2006 10:55AM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Katherine Reece December 06, 2006 11:03AM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Don Barone December 06, 2006 12:35PM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

creigs1707 December 06, 2006 02:16PM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Hermione December 06, 2006 02:22PM

For those like me ...

Don Barone December 06, 2006 08:22PM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

creigs1707 December 06, 2006 02:26PM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

Katherine Reece December 06, 2006 02:27PM

Re: Centroid Alignment Theory (CAT) Stands

creigs1707 December 06, 2006 02:35PM

CAT - The Last Post

creigs1707 December 07, 2006 09:08AM

Re: CAT - The Last Post

C Wayne Taylor December 07, 2006 10:24AM

Re: CAT - The Last Post

Anthony December 07, 2006 11:04AM

Re: CAT - The Last Post

creigs1707 December 07, 2006 11:06AM

Re: CAT - The Last Post

Anthony December 07, 2006 11:32AM

Re: CAT - The Last Post

creigs1707 December 07, 2006 11:46AM

Re: CAT - The Last Post

Anthony December 07, 2006 11:52AM

Re: CAT - The Last Post

creigs1707 December 07, 2006 04:58PM

Thread closed

Katherine Reece December 07, 2006 05:00PM

Re: CAT - The Last Post

C Wayne Taylor December 07, 2006 12:54PM

Re: ROFLMAO!

creigs1707 December 07, 2006 11:42AM



Sorry, you can't reply to this topic. It has been closed.