Home of the The Hall of Ma'at on the Internet
Home
Discussion Forums
Papers
Authors

October 15, 2019, 2:03 am UTC    
July 19, 2019 08:51PM
A comment and reply are now in press for:

Klokocnik, J., Kostelecky, J. and Bezdek, A., 2019.
The putative Saginaw impact structure, Michigan,
Lake Huron, in the light of gravity aspects derived
from recent EIGEN 6C4 gravity field model. Journal
of Great Lakes Research, 45(1), pp.12-20.
Abstract - [www.sciencedirect.com]
PDF - [cosmictusk.com]

Comment

Schaetzl, R. J., Sauck, W., Heinrich, P. V., Colgan,
P. M., and Holliday, V. T., 2019, Commentary on
“Klokocnik, J., Kostelecky, and Bezdek, A. 2019.
The putative Saginaw impact structure,
Michigan, Lake Huron, in the light of gravity
aspects derived from recent EIGEN 6C4
gravity field model.” Journal of Great Lakes
Research. in press.
[www.sciencedirect.com]

Reply

Klokocnik, J., Kostelecky, J. and Bezdek, A., 2019.
Response to comment by Schaetzl et al.(2019) on
“The putative Saginaw impact structure, Michigan,
Lake Huron, in the light of gravity aspects derived
from recent EIGEN 6C4 gravity field model”.
Journal of Great Lakes Research. in press.
[www.sciencedirect.com]

I am somewhat disappointed in the reply as they
simply ignore what my coauthors and I thought
are the major problems with their ideas and leave
unexplained how any sort of airburst, which they
retreated to, can cause any sort of a geophysical
anomaly without visibly disturbing both the
bedrock and overlying Quaternary deposits. Also,
I am not convinced that their pretty geophysical
models reflect reality. Models are not real data.

Yours,

Paul H.

"The past is never dead. It's not even past."
William Faulkner, Act 1, Scene III, Requiem for a Nun (1951)



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 07/20/2019 03:11AM by Hermione.
Subject Author Posted

Younger Dryas - Comment and Reply In Press for Putative Saginaw Bay Impact Paper

Paul H. July 19, 2019 08:51PM

Re: Younger Dryas - Comment and Reply In Press for Putative Saginaw Bay Impact Paper

Hermione July 20, 2019 03:28AM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login