Home of the The Hall of Ma'at on the Internet
Home
Discussion Forums
Papers
Authors

October 13, 2019, 11:34 pm UTC    
August 03, 2019 10:30AM
L Cooper Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> cladking Wrote:
> --------------------------------------------------
> -----
> > So exactly what sort of empirical evidence do
> you
> > have that Faulkner, Allen, Shmakov et al are
> > getting closer and closer to author intent?
>
>
> That is not the way it works. The authors you
> mention have each presented their own cases for
> their interpretations - neither I, nor anyone
> else, need to justify their translations. However,
> if you should disagree with any part of their
> translations, then the onus falls on you, the
> disagreer, to make the case in each instance as to
> where and how they may have erred, and how and why
> your alternate interpretation is to be considered
> more valid.
>
> Shmakov's work is a perfect example of this
> approach. You cite Shmakov, but have you actually
> read his "New Readings"? He disagrees with many of
> the specifics of Allen's PT translations, and in
> each case he then details his argument - providing
> numerous textual examples to help explain and
> support his reasoning behind each suggested
> improvement. He is very clear, very specific, and
> very thorough. There is much to be learned by
> studying his approach. May I suggest that such a
> methodology would serve you infinitely better than
> your apparent penchant for simply relying on
> Mercer as your touchstone.
>

Yes the mystery research and data Sam refuses to release. As far as I can tell his 'study' consists of running 'key words' through an on line and seachable DB.

He has been told what you just correctly stated above hundreds of times .....he refuses to release his material.......
Subject Author Posted

Herodotus Article

L Cooper July 27, 2019 04:28PM

Re: Herodotus Article

Principia July 27, 2019 05:51PM

Re: Herodotus Article

L Cooper July 27, 2019 07:32PM

Re: Herodotus Article

Principia July 28, 2019 12:42AM

Re: Herodotus Article

L Cooper July 28, 2019 05:20PM

Re: Herodotus Article

Principia July 29, 2019 12:28AM

Re: Herodotus Article

L Cooper July 29, 2019 02:41PM

Re: Herodotus Article

Principia July 29, 2019 10:30PM

Re: Herodotus Article

L Cooper July 30, 2019 09:27AM

Re: Herodotus Article

Principia July 30, 2019 12:14PM

Re: Herodotus Article

cladking July 29, 2019 09:42AM

Re: Herodotus Article

Hermione July 30, 2019 06:13AM

Re: Herodotus Article

cladking July 30, 2019 02:13PM

Re: Herodotus Article

Warwick L Nixon August 01, 2019 01:52PM

Re: Herodotus Article

L Cooper August 02, 2019 07:49AM

Re: Herodotus Article

Warwick L Nixon August 02, 2019 02:01PM

Re: Herodotus Article

L Cooper August 02, 2019 08:21PM

Re: Herodotus Article

cladking August 02, 2019 10:36PM

Re: Herodotus Article

L Cooper August 03, 2019 07:49AM

Re: Herodotus Article

Hans August 03, 2019 10:30AM

Re: Herodotus Article

cladking August 03, 2019 01:46PM

Sam

Warwick L Nixon August 03, 2019 04:21PM

Re: Sam

Hans August 03, 2019 10:52PM

Re: Sam

Warwick L Nixon August 04, 2019 12:43AM

Re: Sam

Hans August 04, 2019 01:09PM

Re: Sam

Warwick L Nixon August 05, 2019 12:55PM

Repeating your claims endlessly won't work - publish your research

Hans August 03, 2019 10:11PM

Re: Herodotus Article

Hermione July 28, 2019 04:02AM

Re: Herodotus Article

L Cooper July 28, 2019 07:15AM

Re: Herodotus Article

Hermione July 28, 2019 07:51AM

Re: Herodotus Article

Principia July 28, 2019 05:39PM

Re: On a completely different note...

Rick Baudé August 03, 2019 11:32PM

Re: On a completely different note...

L Cooper August 04, 2019 08:12AM

Re: On a completely different note...

cladking August 04, 2019 08:15AM

Re: On a completely different note...

L Cooper August 04, 2019 08:54AM

Re: On a completely different note...

cladking August 04, 2019 09:04AM

It's always best to publish your ideas

Hans August 04, 2019 11:45PM

Re: On a completely different note...

Hermione August 05, 2019 03:07AM

Re: On a completely different note...

L Cooper August 05, 2019 08:03AM

Re: On a completely different note...

Hans August 05, 2019 10:22AM

Re: On a completely different note...

Rick Baudé August 04, 2019 10:19AM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login